Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 25, 2012 4:27:20 GMT -7
Good Morning. I've been masturbating all my life and although I think its generally okay to do, with all the porn it gets easily out of hand. Sometimes I rub myself raw and can't be as great of lover for my mate. Does anyone else want to chat about keeping their hands off themselves so much?
Thanks in advance for your help.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 25, 2012 5:01:01 GMT -7
People differ, but for me, it's clear that the central issue is porn. I am addicted to porn, and cannot use it in moderation. Like an alcoholic, I need to give it up completely.
So for me, the answer is pretty simple: if I never use porn, then the problem you describe of being led by porn to masturbate excessively goes away.
More broadly, I think porn and masturbation and alcohol are a lot alike. Some of us are addicted to one or more of those things, and some of us are not. For those who aren't addicted, moderating our use may take a little willpower and a little time to develop new habits, but it's not a fundamental problem. Just do it. That was my experience in quitting using alcohol and in dramatically moderating my use of caffeine. For those of us who are addicted, moderating our use isn't an option. It's all or nothing. Either we quit completely or the addictive behavior takes over our lives.
Quitting completely for an addict is hard and scary work, work that involves not just saying no, but rebuilding our relationships with God, with the people around us, and with ourselves in such a way that the fears and resentments that we hide from by withdrawing into our addictive trance are released and no longer need to be medicated in that way. Becoming new people in that way is terrifying, but incredibly rewarding. Since that's not what you want to do, though, I won't waste your time further talking about it.
So I think the bottom line is this: If you want to moderate some habit, just do it. Use less, do something else instead, give yourself little rewards for not using, develop new habits. If, at a later time, you reach the conclusion that that isn't possible and that you are an addict who needs to find recovery, then we can talk about how folks do that. That's the part the sort of people who come to places like this often need, not moderation. If moderation had worked for us, we wouldn't be here.
Tim M.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 25, 2012 5:29:44 GMT -7
Thanks for your reply. I agree that maybe this isn't the place to discuss moderation. But moderation is the key to life. Drinking, smoking, porn and masturbation in moderation isn't bad, like you said its the addictive behavior that gets people in trouble and those people are here. I was in an SSA and they simply said draw a circle and inside put allowable behaviors and outside put unacceptable behaviors. I did that and have been in the circle ever since (never being with anyone else for sex) except my girlfriend. Thanks for your inputs. Have a great day!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 26, 2012 9:03:57 GMT -7
Porn in moderation isn't healthy for the girls your watching though is it. Isn't that like saying watching child porn in moderation is ok?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 26, 2012 10:50:56 GMT -7
No, it isn't healthy for the girls, nor do I think it's healthy for the consumers.
Not everyone agrees with me on this, though, and rather than argue that point, I'd prefer to meet people where they are and to offer support in areas where I feel like I have something to say from experience - sex addiction recovery, for instance. Staying sober myself and helping others desperate for recovery do so as well is work enough without trying to persuade those who are not yet ready to quit that they should do so.
I guess I'm like a Mormon member of AA who has decided to focus my energy on those within the fellowship of AA rather than trying to persuade the world of the evils of drink for everyone. That's not an exact analogy, and in fact I'm neither a Mormon nor an alcoholic, but perhaps it says something about where I am, anyway.
Of course, I can't speak for manwhowantshelp, but if that quick reply seems wrongheaded, I'd be happy to listen further and to continue the conversation.
Tim M.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 27, 2012 9:02:36 GMT -7
You know what. You teach me something everytime. I was battling with my view of society after all this and was troubled about how to deal with it but the way you handle it seems like the best to go. Thanks Tim.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 28, 2012 2:02:55 GMT -7
Well, then let me argue the other side for a moment. I'm not sure what the right course of action is for people who are not addicts, or for those who are neither addicts nor their partners. For somebody to be involved in efforts to protect kids from porn as much as possible or to limit the intrusiveness and ubiquity of porn on the Net is probably a good thing.
I just can't be that person.
The AA Big Book has some useful thoughts on this. It talks about the way in which anger leads to drinking, and it says that we have to stop fighting anything, even alcohol. AA has always been clear that legal and political issues involving alcohol are side issues on which the fellowship has no opinion. Part of the defense of this in the Big Book is because if members of the fellowship are holier than thou about how the whole of society should live, then they are going instantly to turn off the alcoholic who still suffers.
But all those arguments apply to what recovering alcoholics should do individually and collectively. They don't say anything about anyone else. I strongly believe in those AA principles. I also believe that Mothers Against Drunk Driving is a great organization.
And that's where I pretty much have to leave the discussion. If I can't get involved in direct political action, then I also can't get involved in advising others what to do in this regard. In any case, I don't know from experience what helps a wife most - focusing on her own feelings and her own recovery, or working to control the behavior of others for the betterment of society. The small amount of experience I have with Alanon makes me think the former course, which is what you seem to be moving toward in your last post, may make the most sense; but as someone who hasn't been there, my thoughts on that are pretty worthless.
Thanks for listening.
Tim M.
|
|